Scientist Solutions: Life Science Discussions
    
Home » Forums » The Lighter Side of Science » The Rant » Co-author on a paper I have never seen

Thanks to our sponsors who make this site possible

Co-author on a paper I have never seen

RSS Feed

Would you like to save this topic, event, protocol or job so you can find it again easily?

Just click the "Save to My Lab Drawer" link and the item will be saved in the My Lab Drawer section of your bench space.

Available to members only. Please log in or register for your free account now.

G_nome
Canada

Send PM
See Mini bio

Status: Frog Egg
Frog Egg
Topic Started by G_nome
on 1/8/2009 13:51 PM   
Reply to this post Go to the top of the page

I recently was informed by a journal (that shall remain unnammed) that I am co-author on a recently submitted paper. My supervisor got the same email, but neither of us had seen (or heard of) this paper before we got the email. It turns out that the author had used data from one of our recent papers (after asking my permission, which wasn't really necessary, since it was publicly available). He had asked me if it would be OK to include us in the manuscript (mind you, this was a completely different paper, which was rejected). It seems that a second and completely separate manuscript was prepared and submitted completely without our knowledge. Has this ever happened to anyone else? What would you do if this happened to you?


Replies
SMF
United States

Send PM
See Mini bio

Status: Frog Egg
Frog Egg
Posted By SMF
on 1/8/2009 14:15 PM   
Reply to this post Go to the top of the page

This actually just happened to me about a month ago as well. Except I actually did some of the work in the paper. I left the lab and about a year later I found my name as a co-author on a paper i never knew about. I wrote the first author and the last (my old boss) and never got a response. I also wrote the journal and received no response either. I have never even read the paper yet it is published with my name as co-author. Other authors have always sent me a form to verify I have read and approved the paper. I would think all journals should have some system like this in place in order to prevent embarrassing things like retractions if the data is incorrect.



Amtekoth
United States

Send PM
See Mini bio

Status: Lighter Side of Science Moderator
Frog Laureate
Posted By Amtekoth
on 1/8/2009 23:49 PM   
Reply to this post Go to the top of the page

I think it happens much more often that people do the work and DON'T get any credit as authors...

"God put me on this earth to accomplish a certain number of things. Right now I am so far behind that I will never die."- Bill Watterson



PhilM
United Kingdom

Send PM
See Mini bio

Status: Tadpole
Tadpole
Posted By PhilM
on 1/8/2009 22:11 PM   
Reply to this post Go to the top of the page

Don't most journals require ALL the authors to sign the publication license before the paper is published in which they agree that all the authors are aware of the article's content and agree to its the publication in that journal?


Last edited Jan 09, 2009, 0:12 AM by PhilM

Omai
United States

Send PM
See Mini bio

Status: Genetics, Cancer & Bioethics Moderator
Genetics, Cancer & Bioethics Moderator
Posted By Omai
on 1/8/2009 23:32 PM   
Reply to this post Go to the top of the page

Maybe some signatures were forged. You can always email the journal and ask about the signature page.

Omai



G_nome
Canada

Send PM
See Mini bio

Status: Frog Egg
Frog Egg
Posted By G_nome
on 1/9/2009 10:04 AM   
Reply to this post Go to the top of the page

In my case, the paper never went to print (I pulled the plug). The first author apologized and explained that it was the result of a miscommunication (which, I guess, means complete lack of communication). But I agree with other people. How does a paper get into press without a signature from every author? That is not supposed to happen, but for some journals, it seems just the senior/corresponding author has to sign "on behalf of" all other authors.





Jen_Floyd
United States

Send PM
See Mini bio

Status: Moderator
Frog Laureate
Posted By Jen_Floyd
on 1/9/2009 14:36 PM   
Reply to this post Go to the top of the page

That's highly unethical! I would notify the institution and the journal.



hilltrekker
India

Send PM
See Mini bio

Status: Adult Frog
Adult Frog
Posted By hilltrekker
on 3/18/2009 23:36 PM   
Reply to this post Go to the top of the page

PhilM said:
Don't most journals require ALL the authors to sign the publication license before the paper is published in which they agree that all the authors are aware of the article's content and agree to its the publication in that journal?


 


Now there are options to submit the paper for many journals online, where no paper signatures are done.



msvnathan
India

Send PM
See Mini bio

Status: Adult Frog
Adult Frog
Posted By msvnathan
on 3/18/2009 10:35 AM   
Reply to this post Go to the top of the page

hi some journals are even accepting scanned signature. so some time our signature may be scanned and used, it truely ours only but without our permission. These are all ok, but in some cases if they interested they are adding names during the proof time, journals also accepting that. this is bad situation for the student who worked really. a person who is not doing any work, during publication,  the guide's including names of favourite student or his relative or wife's name (if the person in the same subject) in the article.



hilltrekker
India

Send PM
See Mini bio

Status: Adult Frog
Adult Frog
Posted By hilltrekker
on 3/19/2009 20:08 PM   
Reply to this post Go to the top of the page

These things are difficult to control. The cyber frauds are increasing day by day. I think everyone might have come across the fraudualnt emails about their lottery wininng, many people have even lost big chunks of money in this process. A close friend of mine lost a good amount of money this way. So be careful with your money and writings.



armaanster
United Arab Emirates

Send PM
See Mini bio

Status: Tadpole
Tadpole
Posted By armaanster
on 4/19/2009 5:26 AM   
Reply to this post Go to the top of the page

That is worrying, especially if it's a growing threat like people have commented... I know that I would certainly be upset to have my name on a document that I had no part in, and even worse one that I haven't read, as not only is it dishonest, but could also ruin your credibility, making any future work of yours questionable...



As a Scientist Solutions member, you are able to register a positive vote for any topic which you believe is useful and relevant to our board or any reply which you believe is especially well worded and helpful.

By participating in the voting, you will be helping to identify the best topics & replies on the board.

You may vote once for any one post, and you may not vote for your own posts.

A post (topic or reply) will earn one "thumbs up" icon for every 10 votes received (up to 3 thumbs up), and the person who made the post will also earn two bonus points.

learn more about member points.



Click here to
Become a member & join our
community (It's easy & free)
Already a member? Please log in
User Name  
Password  
Forget Password?
Find out about our Rewards System
Scientists
Not finding the answer you need?

Post a new topic

You must be logged in to post. Log in above.
Not a member yet? Click here to register
(it's free)
Thank You to Our Sponsor

The Latest Protocols

No protocols found.

The Latest Events

No events found.