Scientist Solutions: Life Science Discussions
 Refer A Friend    Link To Us    Bookmark Us       

English - Chinese             

Welcome to Scientist Solutions!

You are in The Lighter Side of Science Forum >> Quotes Sub-forum

The peer review system

RSS Feed

Amtekoth
United States

Send PM
See Mini bio

Status: Moderator
Frog Laureate



Topic Started by Amtekoth
on 8/5/2008 12:24 PM
Reply to this post Go to the top of the page
In my considered opinion the peer review system, in which proposals rather than proposers are reviewed, is the greatest disaster visited upon the scientific community in this century. No group of peers would have approved my building the 72-inch bubble chamber. Even Ernest Lawrence told me he thought I was making a big mistake. He supported me because he knew my track record was good. I believe that U.S. science could recover from the stultifying effects of decades of misguided peer reviewing if we returned to the tried-and-true method of evaluating experimenters rather than experimental proposals. Many people will say that my ideas are elitist, and I certainly agree. The alternative is the egalitarianism that we now practice and I've seen nearly kill basic science in the USSR and in the People's Republic of China.
— Luis W. Alvarez
"God put me on this earth to accomplish a certain number of things. Right now I am so far behind that I will never die."- Bill Watterson