Not all manufacturers list EcoRV as having start activity it is true, but there are examples in the literature of it having this activity when used in excess
Fixing star activity
Use as few units as possible to get a complete digestion. This avoids overdigestion and reduces the final glycerol concentration in the reaction.
Make sure the reaction is free of any organic solvents such as alcohols which might be present in the DNA preparation.
Raise the ionic strength of the reaction buffer to 100-150 mM (provided the enzyme is not inhibited by high salt).
Lower the pH of the reaction buffer to pH 7.0.
Use Mg++ as the divalent cation.
Alternative explainations may include things such as the strain of bacteria that you use can also effect the cutting patterns. If you do not purify the plasmids well enough in some cases there may well be trace nuclease activity. This generally applies when using endA+ strains like HB101 or JM series bacteria.
Here's a cute refernce to explain things
http://www.promega.com/pnotes/53/5015j6/5015j6_core.pdfIf you are using XL-1 blue or DH5alpha this is unlikely to be such a problem.
Alternatively if you really think you have a mixed sample of plasmid, find a different enzyme that is unique. When you cut with that you should see the appropriate sized linear band on your gel. Even if you have extra bands cut out the one that is the expected size, purify it then religate it and then transform into E. coli. Sequence a small section to confirm identity if the plasmid.
Good luck