Scientist Solutions: International Life Science Community By Scientists For Scientists
    
Home » Forums » Analytical Chemistry » Environmental Analysis: Wet Chemical » Spectrophotometer Comparison

Thanks to our sponsors who make this site possible

Spectrophotometer Comparison

RSS Feed

Would you like to save this topic, event, protocol or job so you can find it again easily?

Just click the "Save to My Lab Drawer" link and the item will be saved in the My Lab Drawer section of your bench space.

Available to members only. Please log in or register for your free account now.

ToxLabRat
United States

Send PM
See Mini bio

Status: Frog Laureate
Frog Laureate
Topic Started by ToxLabRat
on 11/4/2010 1:12 AM   
Reply to this post Go to the top of the page

I am looking into getting a new benchtop spectrophotometer.  The one we currently have is an old Hach unit.  I have found a few that I am comparing the specifications on, however I would greatly appreciate your thoughts and experiences with spectrophotometers, especially if you have used one of the brands I am looking at.  The Unico model is extremely well priced and it seems to have almost the exact same specs as the Hach and Thermo, however I have never used anything manufactured by this company, so if you have, then please let me know what you think.

Unico S-1205E
Hach DR/2800
Hach DR/3800
Thermo Scientific-15001-200

Thanks in advance for your help!

Tox

If you are not part of the solution, then you are part of the percipitate!


Replies
metalman694
United States

Send PM
See Mini bio

Status: Frog Laureate
Frog Laureate
Posted By metalman694
on 11/16/2010 7:41 AM   
Reply to this post Go to the top of the page

I've never had a hand in selecting spectrophotometers in the lab, but I can tell you from experience that we only use Beckman here, and they are very rugged and perform well.  As a matter of fact, we are probably due to get a new one soon since the one we currently use is getting pretty old.  Even after all this time of heavy use it still performs well.  I'm not sure what the price ranges are, but from an analyst standpoint, I really like the Beckman models.  I've used others at school (Hach and Thermo I believe) but I always liked the Beckman better.  We currently use a Beckman DU 640 (probably not made anymore) and we also have a very old Beckman DU 64 which surprisingly works well still considering it's age.  I've talked to collegues at trade shows and they like Beckmans also.

Hope this helps!

-Metalman



Rajiv Dua
India

Send PM
See Mini bio

Status: Adult Frog
Adult Frog
Posted By Rajiv Dua
on 8/25/2011 2:55 AM   
Reply to this post Go to the top of the page

Beckman models are best ....even we are using Beckman Du 800 for last 5 years ...No problem

Learning is a treasure that will follow its owner everywhere.....RD



As a Scientist Solutions member, you are able to register a positive vote for any topic which you believe is useful and relevant to our board or any reply which you believe is especially well worded and helpful.

By participating in the voting, you will be helping to identify the best topics & replies on the board.

You may vote once for any one post, and you may not vote for your own posts.

A post (topic or reply) will earn one "thumbs up" icon for every 10 votes received (up to 3 thumbs up), and the person who made the post will also earn two bonus points.

learn more about member points.